Agency Selection & Audit
Ads with one agency, SEO with another, content with a third. Each brings its own report, and nobody can see the overall result in one place. We review your agencies' work with an independent eye, sort out where each piece of work belongs, and set things up so you get the right work from your agency at the right price.
Agency selection and audit means independently reviewing the work and accounts of the agencies you use, sorting out what should move in-house, what can be automated and what belongs with a specialist agency, and setting up the brief, pitch and contract process for choosing a new agency.
Sound familiar?
Most agency problems come from scope, measurement and ownership never being written down. An agency does what it's asked to do; if the ask isn't clear, neither is the result. The signs below point to that lack of clarity.
- You work with several agencies but can't measure the overall result
- The agency reports look good while sales stay flat
- Your ad accounts or website are registered in the agency's name
- It isn't clear what work the agency fee actually covers
- You think some of the work could now be done in-house but don't know where to start
- You're looking for a new agency but have nothing to compare the proposals against
How we work
We independently review your agencies' work, their reports, and your ad, analytics and website accounts.
We sort the work into three groups: what can move in-house, what can be automated and what should stay with a specialist agency.
We prepare a proposal to simplify your agency list and, if you need a new agency, the brief and pitch pack.
We tighten the scope, measurement, data and account ownership clauses in your contracts and stay with you through the selection.
Our team spent years on the agency side and knows what a good agency brings. In this work, our aim is to make sure you get the right work from your agency at the right price. The audit looks at the work itself and backs every finding with data from the accounts, and we write the report clearly enough that you can share it with your agency.
Clauses every agency contract should have
Most agency contracts state the fee and the term, but not how the work will be measured or who owns what gets built. In the audit we add these clauses to your current contracts, and in a selection we add them to the new one:
- Scope: what work is done, how often and with which deliverables
- Measurement: which number, in which tool and under which definition counts as success
- Data ownership: campaign, analytics and CRM data belong to the company
- Account ownership: ad accounts, the domain and the website are registered in the company's name, with the agency only given access
- Exit and handover: how accounts, files and knowledge are handed over when the contract ends
Week by week
- Week 1
- Review. We gather your agencies' work, reports and contracts, and look at your ad, analytics and website accounts with read-only access. We put what each agency does, and for what fee, into one table.
- Weeks 2 and 3
- Audit and sorting. We audit the setup and results in the accounts and sort each piece of work into in-house, automation or specialist agency. We go through the findings and the agency map with you. If you only want the audit, the work ends here.
- Weeks 4 to 6
- Brief and selection. If you need a new agency, we prepare the brief and pitch pack, write the criteria for comparing proposals and join you in the pitch meetings. We finalize the contract clauses with the agency you choose.
Typical length
3 to 6 weeks.
What you get
Audit report, agency map, brief and pitch pack, contract clauses.
- Audit report: each agency's work, the setup and results in the accounts, with evidence
- Agency map: what moves in-house, what goes to automation and what stays with a specialist agency
- Brief and pitch pack: needs, scope, budget frame and the criteria for comparing proposals
- Contract clauses: scope, measurement, data and account ownership, exit and handover
Who it's for
A good fit
- Companies working with several agencies that want to measure the overall result
- Managers who want to see clearly what the agency fees pay for
- Marketing teams thinking about bringing some work in-house
- Companies that want to pin down their needs before choosing a new agency
- Anyone who wants to be sure their accounts and data belong to them
Not a good fit
- Anyone looking only for a report to blame their current agency
- Companies that can't give read-only access to their accounts
- Anyone looking for an agency for one small job with a scope that's already clear
- Anyone who wants to hand all the work to us instead of agencies; in that case, see our services
What we measure
We take the same measurements at the start and at the end of the project, and read the difference with you.
- Total agency cost: how the fees paid to all agencies split across the work
- Scope clarity: the share of work whose contract spells out scope, measurement and deliverables
- Account ownership: the share of ad, analytics and website accounts registered in the company's name
- Measurable work: the share of agency work measured against a shared number
- Duplicate work: work done at the same time by more than one agency, or by an agency and the in-house team
Frequently asked questions
Should our current agency know about the audit?
It's better if they do. The audit is there to improve the work, so there's no need to keep it from them. We write the findings so you can share them with your agency, and if you like, we invite the agency to the results meeting too.
Do you recommend a specific agency?
Instead of recommending a specific agency, we give you a pitch pack so you can compare proposals against the same criteria. We join you in the pitch meetings; the choice stays with you.
Will we have to stop working with our agency after the audit?
Not necessarily. The point of the audit is to put the scope in the right place. Some work may move in-house, some may be automated, and specialist work stays with the agency.
Which accounts do you need access to for the audit?
Read-only access to your ad and analytics accounts, and to the website and CRM where needed. We don't ask for admin rights, and you remove the access when the work is done.
Can a team that worked on the agency side stay impartial?
Knowing the agency side means knowing what's reasonable. We know from the inside how much effort a piece of work takes and what a report shows or leaves out. We base the assessment on data from the accounts.
Whether you know the problem or not, we can start here.
Last updated: